========================================================================== ------------------------------------------------------------------- Guideline for the Comments about the Papers of the GCSE 2000 - YRW: ------------------------------------------------------------------- Paper Title: ........................................... Authors: ........................................... Panelist: ........................................... Overall Judgement / Assessment / Estimation: -------------------------------------------- excellent [] very good [] good [] some ideas are questionable [] the overall concept is questionable [] Short Summary of the most interesting or important Results and Ideas of the Paper: (*) -------------------------------------------------------------- ...... Originality: ------------ unacceptable [] marginally acceptable [] acceptable [] excellent [] rationale: ...... Practical Relevance: -------------------- unacceptable [] marginally acceptable [] acceptable [] excellent [] rationale: ...... Presentation & Organization: ---------------------------- unacceptable [] marginally acceptable [] acceptable [] excellent [] rationale: ...... Points in Favor: Positive Aspects of the Work What is good? What is worth keeping? ------------------------------------------------------------- ...... Points against / that are weak / that should not be followed: ------------------------------------------------------------- ...... Proposals for further Research (within the Context of the Paperīs Content) and Suggestions for major Improvements: -------------------------------------------------------------------------- ...... In which specific Direction would you encourage the Author to push on? --------------------------------------------------------------------------- ...... If necessary, are you willing to give further Feedback for the future Work of the Authors? ------------------------------------------------------ yes [] no [] ---------------------------------------------------------------- (*) This is only for the written comments. Due to hard time limitations during the Workshop, it should be avoided to give a summary of the presentation. ==========================================================================